The race and ethnicity questions in research design have been discussed and debated for many years. Two important issues in the debate are a) should the (esp., race) question even be asked? and b) if so, what is the best way to word these questions to gain some true (objective or subjective) measure. Rubén Rumbaut addressed the first issue in his March 2011 interview on NPR’s Morning Edition (as well as his 2009 paper, “Pigments of our imagination: On the racialization and racial identities of ‘Hispanics’ and ‘Latinos’”) where he maintains that asking the race question is more about “social status” and putting people “in their place” than about understanding “a natural, fixed marker…inherent in human bodies.” In a similar vein, fellow research blogger Jeffrey Henning concludes his February 2009 post on race and ethnicity by saying, “I look forward to the day when race and ethnicity are no longer standard demographic questions, and when skin color is no more important than hair color or eye color.”
If race and ethnicity questions are to be asked (and there are reasons for asking these questions, particularly when civil rights and money are involved), how should we ask them? It is generally accepted practice in the federal government – Census Bureau, FDA, Department of Education, Department of Defense – to distinguish between race and ethnicity, acknowledging that race refers to a population’s physical characteristics while ethnicity speaks to “social groups with a shared history, sense of identity, geography, and cultural roots.” This is especially important as Hispanics become a commanding segment in the U.S. population. As anyone who completed last year’s Census form can tell you, the convention is to first ask the ethnicity question – “Is this person of Hispanic, Latino, or Spanish origin?” – followed by the race question – “What is this person’s race?”
Outside the federal government, the thinking behind race-ethnicity question design seems murky. In some instances no distinction is made between race and ethnicity*:
To which racial or ethnic group(s) do you most identify?
Latino or Hispanic
Native American or Aleut
Would you describe yourself as:
American Indian/Native American
How would you classify yourself?
While others are confused by what is “race” and what is “ethnicity”*:
What is your race?
What is your ethnicity?
Every researcher on every study needs to decide whether the race-ethnicity questions provide meaningful, actionable information. If these questions are deemed appropriate, careful design considerations are imperative to giving the respondent a clear path to response.
* Examples taken from actual survey questionnaires
I even feel there are some options missing in some categories. Brazilian identity for instance is completely misunderstood by non Latin-Americans. Expecting us to answer “hispanic” is unrealistic because of its “Spanish” signifiers, to which Brazil simply does not relate. Expecting us to identify as hispanic would be expecting Americans to identify themselves as germanic.
Above all, there are practical implications: apart from having different cultural references, we speak Portuguese, and this turns out to be a serious language barrier in speech. It render us actual foreigners within hispanic communities, with all the struggles that comes in the package. What good is it to form a ghetto within a ghetto?
The issue of having to select one over another can easily be bypassed by making the question of race and/or ethnicity into a ‘select all that apply’ type of question. That is what we did in a survey I recently digitized using KoboCollect.
I’m a white Hispanic.
well my mother is Biracial , she West Indian mixed with African American & My father on the other hand is full black (African American) , I don’t know of I would consider myself biracial or not … Does having one mixed parent still put you in the category of being biracial
Is it just me,or does a tiny part of your personality actually made by your ethnicity?Because I usually think of myself as someone who is calm and contempletive,and that’s how people often react when you ask where they are from.